Average cost per minute of EHR downtime in healthcare settings
When we talk about healthcare IT security, the conversation usually jumps straight to ransomware and hackers. But there's a quieter threat that catches far more practices off guard: backup failures.
The numbers are sobering. In 2025, OCR closed 9 investigations with financial penalties specifically for HIPAA risk analysis failures—and backup inadequacy was a common finding. Small practices, which already bear 55% of all HIPAA fines, are disproportionately affected because they often rely on backup systems that haven't been tested in years, if ever.
The Real Cost of "Good Enough" Backups
Most healthcare organizations think about backups in terms of data loss. But the true cost of backup failure goes far beyond missing files:
- Operational paralysis: When your EHR goes down and backups fail to restore quickly, every minute costs an average of $7,900. A full day of downtime can reach $1.9 million.
- Regulatory exposure: HIPAA requires covered entities to maintain retrievable exact copies of electronic PHI. If you can't prove your backup works, you're already non-compliant.
- Patient safety: 54% of organizations that experienced ransomware attacks reported increased medical procedure complications. Without accessible patient data, clinical decisions become dangerous guesses.
- Reputation damage: Healthcare data breaches affected 57 million individuals in 2025. Patients are paying attention.
The 5 Backup Mistakes Putting Your Practice at Risk
1. "We Have Backups" Without Testing Them
The most common backup failure isn't a technical glitch—it's assumption. Many practices set up backups years ago and never verify they actually work. OCR investigators consistently find organizations that assumed their backups were running, only to discover during an incident that the backup process had failed months earlier.
Reality check: If you haven't performed a full restore test in the past 90 days, you don't actually know if your backups work.
2. Relying on a Single Backup Location
On-site backups are convenient until they're not. A ransomware attack that encrypts your main servers will often target connected backup drives too. Fire, flood, or theft can eliminate both your primary data and your only backup simultaneously.
The HIPAA Security Rule's contingency plan standards (45 CFR 164.308(a)(7)) specifically require that you can restore PHI in the event of a disaster. Single-location backups rarely meet this standard.
3. Backup Intervals That Don't Match Your Risk
Weekly backups might seem reasonable—until you realize that means potentially losing a full week of patient records, billing data, and clinical notes. For a busy practice seeing 30 patients daily, that's 150+ patient encounters you'd need to reconstruct from memory and paper notes.
Consider: What's the maximum amount of data your practice can afford to lose? That answer should determine your backup frequency, not the other way around.
4. Ignoring Backup Encryption
Unencrypted backups are a HIPAA violation waiting to happen. If a backup drive is lost or stolen and the data isn't encrypted, you're required to report a breach—even though the data was "just a backup." The HHS breach portal shows numerous incidents where unencrypted backup media resulted in notifications to thousands of patients.
5. No Documentation or Recovery Procedures
When your main IT person is on vacation and your system crashes, can someone else execute a restore? OCR expects documented disaster recovery procedures that any trained staff member can follow. "Only I know how it works" is not a compliance strategy.
What HIPAA Actually Requires for Backups
The HIPAA Security Rule doesn't prescribe specific technologies, but it does require:
- Data backup plan (§164.308(a)(7)(ii)(A)): Establish and implement procedures to create and maintain retrievable exact copies of ePHI.
- Disaster recovery plan (§164.308(a)(7)(ii)(B)): Establish procedures to restore any loss of data.
- Emergency mode operation plan (§164.308(a)(7)(ii)(C)): Enable continuation of critical business processes.
- Testing and revision (§164.308(a)(7)(ii)(D)): Implement procedures for periodic testing and revision of contingency plans.
The key word is "implement"—not just document. OCR investigators look for evidence that these plans have been tested and updated. A backup policy gathering dust in a drawer won't protect you during an audit.
Building a Backup Strategy That Actually Works
A compliant, reliable backup system follows the 3-2-1 rule:
- 3 copies of your data: Production data plus two backups
- 2 different storage types: Local and cloud, or different media types
- 1 copy off-site: Geographically separate from your primary location
Beyond the basic structure, your backup strategy should include:
- Automated verification: Systems that confirm backup completion and data integrity without human intervention
- Immutable backups: Storage that can't be modified or deleted by ransomware, even if attackers compromise administrative credentials
- Defined RTOs and RPOs: How quickly can you restore (Recovery Time Objective) and how much data can you afford to lose (Recovery Point Objective)?
- Quarterly restore testing: Full restoration to verify your backups actually work, documented for compliance purposes
The 2026 Compliance Deadline Approaching
HHS finalized key updates to the HIPAA Privacy Rule in 2024, with a critical compliance deadline of February 16, 2026. The updated Security Rule is expected to be finalized soon, making system-level, ongoing risk analysis a baseline expectation rather than a periodic task.
This means the era of annual HIPAA check-ups is ending. OCR wants to see continuous compliance—including continuous verification that your backup and disaster recovery systems function as intended.
For small practices already stretched thin, this raises a practical question: Do you have the internal capacity to manage continuous backup monitoring and compliance documentation?
Is Your Practice at Risk?
Take our free 2-minute IT Health Assessment to identify backup vulnerabilities and HIPAA compliance gaps before they become costly problems.
The Bottom Line
Backup failures aren't just IT problems—they're business continuity risks, patient safety issues, and compliance liabilities wrapped into one. The practices that weather ransomware attacks, natural disasters, and OCR audits aren't the ones with the fanciest technology. They're the ones that test their backups, document their procedures, and treat disaster recovery as an ongoing process rather than a one-time project.
The question isn't whether your practice will face a data emergency. It's whether you'll be ready when it happens.